Tuesday, August 27, 2013

Am I Overly Sensitive to Noise?

        I try hard not be be an irritable old woman, constantly complaining about every little thing, especially in this blog, which is supposed to focus on cross-cultural comparisons.  But some venting is in order here, though I'm going to try hard to keep it "fair and balanced," like the Fox TV Network in the USA (Ha, ha!)  

     One of the most noticeable differences between Japan and Malaysia, it seems to me, is the tolerance for noise and what the nationals of each country find acceptable.  Coming back to Penang after a few months in Japan, I've found myself even more intolerant of ambient noise than usual.  So let me muse about it here, please.  
   
 First, let me point out that both countries have their own versions of noise pollution.  Take Japan, for instance.  Personally, I would maintain that Japan is a blessedly quiet country, one where you can ride a train or dine in almost-unearthly silence (unless junior high school kids are present).  It's a place where at night, except for the occasional "bosozoku" motorcycle rider, it's sosilent you can sleep, and even sleep in.  But then, I live out in the countryside where it's pretty unusual to have as many as three cars waiting in a line for the traffic light to change.  I enjoy that peace and tranquility.

    Others would disagree, saying that Japan is full of noise pollution.  But I maintain that on the personal level, the Japanese are generally quiet and like a peaceful atmosphere. However, I'll admit that on the official level, it's another story, especially when it comes to public safety.  Schools' PA systems blare out disaster-preparedness sounds to test them.  There are endless recorded announcements about standing behind the yellow line on train platforms, about how to ride an escalator safely, about being careful of this, that or the other thing.  Trucks have a whole vocabulary of beeps, announcements and warning sounds when they're about to make a turn, back up, or do anything besides go forward in a straight line. Stores are full of recorded messages about products for sale. Some run incessantly, while others are motion-sensor activated. They only bug you as you pass by, which is probably appreciated by the clerks who have to work within earshot of them. Buses and trains have plenty of recorded announcements which, by the way, are appreciated by the blind, at least the ones about when and where the transport will stop next.  Yup--many would declare Japan to be a really noisy country.

   In fact, recently there's been a big furor in Japan because the ever-increasing elderly population is becoming quite vociferous about and intolerant of the noise produced by children playing or students doing their extracurricular activities.  Check out this link for an interesting article about this problem.  http://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2013/06/04/national/hey-kids-keep-it-down-graying-japan-annoyed-by-childrens-noise/#.UhvGBxxNCAY
Despite the fact that there are fewer and fewer kids born in Japan these days, there are more and more senior citizens who object to the cheerful sounds they produce.  What a conundrum, especially if it gives already-reluctant couples even one more reason not to reproduce! 

     So how about Malaysia?  Well, I don't think there's anyone who would claim that this "cheerfully chaotic" country is anything but noisy! Traffic, hawkers, groups of young people out celebrating a friend's birthday, kids shrieking and running around. Raucous mobile phone ring tones.  Even the bird calls are loud, varied and continuous, at least in the mornings.  But they're one of the things I love most about living where we do.  It's like living in the aviary at a zoo!  And some of those birds will reply if even an amateur like me calls out to them.  But I digress. . . . 
    
   What I surmise -- and I'm not alone, of course -- is that Malaysians have a higher tolerance for noise than people of many other countries.  Perhaps they don't even hear it.  In fact, they might even think something was wrong if they didn't.  If you've grown up with the five-times-a-day calls-to-prayer from Muslim mosques, I guess you'd think something was wrong if they suddenly disappeared. Personally, I think they're a wonderful part of the multi-cultural diversity of Malaysia.  But then, I'm not living right next to a mosque; you'd hear quite a different opinion from my expat friends who do. 

    In my next post, I want to tell you about my recent success at extinguishing a particularly irritating source of noise pollution.  Stay tuned!

   

     


     

2 comments:

  1. Try living next to the "Floating Mosque in Tanjung Bungah/Batu Ferringhi" (Ma'had Tahfiz Al-Quran Kasyfu Al-Umum) and you will experience the perfect noise pollution direct - five times a day. Why? The particular mosque has installed a LOUD PA system so that all ex-pats, tourists, other religious denominations and locals alike are forced to listen to the "sermon" five times a day!!! Yes, it is fine to make the arabic call to prayer but according to local muslims (whom I have spoken to and whom are also a fed up of hearing the imposed sermons) have informed me that the sermon should not be heard via a PA loudspeaker system. Lots of hotels in the area are losing business because of it and lots of MM2H residents within the nearby 4 miles zone from teh mosque, have called it quits and either returned home or have relocated to other places within Malaysia. What happened to Malaysia Satu - 1Malaysia?? How can the said mosque defy the practices of all other mosques throughout Malaysia by insisting that all and sundry are compelled to hear the sermon teachings - even if done in a most fanatical way. Many tourists within the area have said that they will never ever return to Penang.............. bad for tourism, all because of the irresponsibility and religious demands of a few over the vast numbers of ""frightened to say anything"" local population. I praise Japan for its true way of treating others with honest sincerity, respect and politeness to wards others.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I am an American businessman who has been working and living in Tanjung Bunga are for 8 years now. I totally agree that since the PA system was installed at the Floating Mosque a few years ago, the five times a day loud fanatic sermons are considered by 95% of the local inhabitants is beyond belief. Surely, it is not done in other mosques (having lived next to quite a few in my long stay in Malaysia). Not only is it a loud nuisance but has dramatically pushed down the prices of all apartments, businesses and real-estate in the area. I too have noticed tourists and MM2H people complaining as well as the thousands of locals here during the past 3 years. Yes, I agree with the comment above that the mosque has the right to make call to prayer - but not to noisely broadcast the sermon - in Malay - not even in Arabic, Chinese, Indian or English!!!! The Malays are outnumbered in the area. I urge all tourists, returning MM2H residents, and visitors to the area to write to their newspapers and write to their Malaysian Ambassadors in their countries in order to warn future visitors and tourists and retired people NOT to stay in the affected area. Let us close down their nearby hotels and businesses until they see sense and ban this disgraceful five-times-a-day shouting and until we re-gain 1Malaysia. Lastly, what if it was a christian church or Indian temple make such a nuisance of itself? I am sure that the authorities and the syariah lot would soon be "up in arms" as they do in so many of the middle-eastern countries.

    ReplyDelete